lunes, octubre 26, 2009

cornsitution

article from grist:
by TOM PHILPOTT
What do industrially produced meat and corn-based ethanol have in common?

Well, they both thrive on the assumption that it’s good idea to devote vast swaths of land to an incredibly resource-intensive crop—corn—and then run that crop through an energy-sucking process to create a product of dubious value.

And .. they both got tagged as major drivers of climate change this past week.

Ethanol took the harder blow of the two, I think. It came wrapped in the Oct. 23 issue of Science. In a concise and devastating “policy forum” piece, a team of authors led by University of Minnesota researcher Tim Searchinger fingered a gaping defect in existing European and pending U.S. climate policy: biofuel gets treated as carbon-neutral, ignoring carbon emissions from land-use change. According to the paper ($ub req’d), the Kyoto Protocol, the European Union’s cap-and-trade law, and the final version of Waxman-Markey (the House climate bill that passed over the summer) all contain the a “far-reaching but fixable flaw”:

[They] does not count CO2 emitted from tailpipes and smokestacks when bioenergy is being used, but it also does not count changes in emissions from land use when biomass for energy is harvested or grown. This accounting erroneously treats all bioenergy as carbon neutral regardless of the source of the biomass, which may cause large differences in net emissions. For example, the clearing of long-established forests to burn wood or to grow energy crops is counted as a 100% reduction in energy emissions despite causing large releases of carbon.

Or, as Searchinger put it to a Wall Street Journal reporter, “Literally, in theory, if you chopped up the Amazon, turned it into a parking lot, and burned the wood in a power plant, that would be treated as a carbon-emissions reduction strategy.”

The implications of the flaw are staggering: existing climate law, coupled with U.S. and European biofuel mandates, could lead to vast forest clearing—unleashing a gusher of greenhouse gases in the name of … averting climate change. That’s sort of like trying to save your sight by gouging out your eyes. The authors state:

One study estimated that a global CO2 target of 450 ppm under this accounting would cause bioenergy crops to expand to displace virtually all the world’s natural forests and savannahs by 2065, releasing up to 37 gigatons (Gt) of CO2 per year (comparable to total human CO2 emissions today). Another study predicts that, based solely on economic considerations, bioenergy could displace 59% of the world’s natural forest cover and release an additional 9 Gt of CO2 per year to achieve a 50% “cut” in greenhouse gases by 2050. The reason: When bioenergy from any biomass is counted as carbon neutral, economics favor large-scale land conversion for bioenergy regardless of the actual net emissions. [Emphasis added.]

It should be noted that this “flaw” in U.S. climate policy is no accident. House Ag committee chair Collin Peterson fought like a pitbull to enshrine it in Waxman-Markey. To the agribusiness lobby Pererson represents, tarnishing the good name of ethanol is tantamount to setting fire to a Bible during Sunday school.

Another article in the same Science issue explores another massive problem with biofuels: water scarcity. As the author puts it: “A widespread shift toward biofuels could pinch water supplies and worsen water pollution. In short, an increased reliance on biofuel trades an oil problem for a water problem.” (Emphasis added.) According to the author, it takes between 90 and 190 liters of water to extract a kilowat-hour worth of oil. To get thhe same amount of energy from corn-based ethanol? Try 2.2 and 8.6 million liters of water. Ouch.

As for meat, get this: two researchers associated with the World Bank claim in a new World Watch piece (PDF) that meat production is responsible for more than half of global greenhouse gas emissions. Previously, the most widely cited estimate came from the FAO, which reckoned meat contributes an already-stunning 18 percent.

So why the difference in assessments? The biggest factor is respiration—the breathing out of C02—by livestock. According to the authors, livestock respiration adds massive carbon to the atmosphere—that factor alone, they claim, is equal to 13 percent of global annual GHG emissions.

I don’t have the scientific chops to assess their reasoning. I do wonder if the vast number if the C02 breathed into the air by farm animals isn’t partially offset by the vast number of wild animals elimainated by meat production. It’s not a pretty thoughtm but think of the habitat swallowed up by corn and soy fields globally—and the billions of animals who now monger exist to breathe out carbon.

However, I agree that meat production is deeply implicated in climate change—and must be cut dramatically. But I find these authors’ conclusion stunning: They want to replace industrially raised meat with industrially raised soy. In place of a chicken in every pot, they want to see a “chicken” in every pot. They call on the food industry to dramatically scale up the production of highly processed fake meat—and even offer marketing advice. They declare:

A successful campaign would avoid negative themes and stress positive ones. For instance, recommending that meat not be eaten one day per week suggests deprivation. Instead, the campaign should pitch the theme of eating all week long a line of food products that is tasty, easy to prepare, and includes a “superfood,” such as soy, that will enrich their lives.

They also express enthusiasm for “artificial meat cultivated in laboratories from cells originating from livestock, sometimes called ‘in vitro’ meat.”

Sorry, but given ideas like that, I’m not ready to let a couple of World Bank guys dictate the future of cuisine. Getting a carnivorous culture to reduce meat consumption is going to be tricky no matter what. Rather than push folks to embrace soy weenies and test-tube “shmeat,” I’d rather see a revival of minimally processed rice and beans, a move toward meat as a side dish, and a return to diversified farming that uses manageable amounts of manure to nourish cropland. Let’s ban the CAFO—but not eviscerate what’s left of our palates.



http://www.grist.org/article/2009-10-23-corn-meat-ethanol-global-warming/

Etiquetas: , ,

32 Comentarios:

Anonymous Anónimo dijo...

FqiQva [url=http://canadagoosejacketsite.com/]canada goose jacket[/url] WluQda QswMmp http://canadagoosejacketsite.com/ ObxSem OozJnv [url=http://canadagoosejacketclub.com/]canada goose sale[/url] XtfSaq XufUee http://canadagoosejacketclub.com/ QyhNkf ZygKlr [url=http://canadagooseoutlettoca.com/] canada goose parka[/url] EtgGxz RstKtm http://canadagooseoutlettoca.com/ LqiHll MgqFli [url=http://canadagoosesalehome.com/]canada goose[/url] FloNwz JxwAhl http://canadagoosesalehome.com/ DhlIrh

3:20 a.m.  
Anonymous Anónimo dijo...

JtcNar [url=http://cheapggboots.com/]cheap ugg boots[/url] BhrAxx HjlJao http://cheapggboots.com/ JmoXle PirOvt [url=http://parka2013.com/] canada goose jacket[/url] WvgJaz MroHbc http://parka2013.com/ IetPle TbjJes [url=http://cagoosehome.com/]canada goose jackets[/url] BbfSyt NekIcd http://cagoosehome.com/ IxcGjq DgaVsh [url=http://jackets-2012.com/] Canada Goose Parka[/url] JitBdx NfuBwe http://jackets-2012.com/ UfxHlr ZpjPnm [url=http://gooseoutlet2013.com/]Canada Goose Outlet[/url] JvgNzq LnbSnc http://gooseoutlet2013.com/ AamSii UztJhd [url=http://jacketsca.com/]canada goose jacket[/url] PfbJjl FddKnc http://jacketsca.com/ VosJti

1:38 p.m.  
Anonymous Anónimo dijo...

SuoQmn [url=http://ukbootshopon.com/]office ugg boots[/url] SlbMvw http://ukbootshopon.com/

5:09 p.m.  
Anonymous Anónimo dijo...

qyvygq [url=http://canada-goose-sales.ca]Canada Goose Sale[/url] bepwnp http://canada-goose-sales.ca ayeqou [url=http://canadagooseoutletss.com]Canada Goose Outlet[/url] jkjuzu http://canadagooseoutletss.com fcxsss [url=http://salecanadagooseoutlet.ca]Canada Goose Outlet[/url] iaraao http://salecanadagooseoutlet.ca ntgufl [url=http://mycanadagoose-canada.com]Canada Goose Jackets[/url] tdbaxt http://mycanadagoose-canada.com asdaas [url=http://salecanadagoose-outlets.com]Canada Goose Outlet[/url] npmuad http://salecanadagoose-outlets.com fwnahj [url=http://salecanaadagoosejackets.ca]Canada Goose Jackets[/url] nsuyot http://salecanaadagoosejackets.ca bizcce

10:55 a.m.  
Anonymous Anónimo dijo...

AhcXxr [url=http://ghdshairscarestore.com/]ghd[/url] UsfOnk http://ghdshairscarestore.com/ MpmYts [url=http://ghdshairscareshop.com/]ghd straighteners[/url] GueFkn http://ghdshairscareshop.com/ IsrQic [url=http://ghdshaircarestore.com/]cheap ghd hair straighteners[/url] GqwPtu http://ghdshaircarestore.com/ ZojEvk [url=http://ghdshaircareshop.com/]ghd straightener[/url] GlmPaj http://ghdshaircareshop.com/ HuaHxt [url=http://ghdhairscarestore.com/]cheap ghd[/url] AzqJsc http://ghdhairscarestore.com/ XwaNhg [url=http://ghdhairscaresshop.com/]ghd factory outlet[/url] SguKnd http://ghdhairscaresshop.com/ DoxFjt [url=http://ghdhaircarestore.com/]ghd outlet[/url] MplJsi http://ghdhaircarestore.com/ HuiAmp [url=http://ghdhaircaresstore.com/]ghd australia[/url] ArbMao http://ghdhaircaresstore.com/ YsyLmg [url=http://ghdhaircareshop.com/]ghd straighteners australia[/url] PbjBcj http://ghdhaircareshop.com/

11:20 a.m.  
Anonymous Anónimo dijo...

viagra online buy viagra in us - cheap viagra side effects

12:37 p.m.  
Anonymous Anónimo dijo...

cheap generic viagra anyone ever buy viagra online - order viagra online in toronto on

12:48 a.m.  
Anonymous Anónimo dijo...

generic viagra how to buy viagra us - does viagra work in young men

3:53 p.m.  
Anonymous Anónimo dijo...

buy soma soma yahoo answers - online soma sales

3:29 a.m.  
Anonymous Anónimo dijo...

buy soma soma generic - buy soma online with paypal

8:47 a.m.  
Anonymous Anónimo dijo...

where to buy tramadol buy tramadol online bluelight - recovering tramadol addiction

6:03 a.m.  
Anonymous Anónimo dijo...

buy cialis buy cialis online forum - best place buy cialis online us

12:15 a.m.  
Anonymous Anónimo dijo...

buy cialis online buy cialis online usa no prescription - generic cialis bangkok

12:28 p.m.  
Anonymous Anónimo dijo...

buy tramadol buy ultram tramadol online - tramadol 50 mg long term use

2:09 a.m.  
Anonymous Anónimo dijo...

buy tramadol can you buy tramadol otc - buy tramadol texas

4:28 p.m.  
Anonymous Anónimo dijo...

carisoprodol without prescription carisoprodol abuse effects - carisoprodol 350 mg is used for

4:43 a.m.  
Anonymous Anónimo dijo...

buy tramadol tramadol get high off it - tramadol legal to buy online

6:57 a.m.  
Anonymous Anónimo dijo...

buy cheap carisoprodol carisoprodol us - carisoprodol recreational dose

2:47 p.m.  
Anonymous Anónimo dijo...

buy cialis online best price cialis sydney - cialis online usa pharmacy

2:19 p.m.  
Anonymous Anónimo dijo...

buy carisoprodol carisoprodol 350 mg tab qualitest - carisoprodol 446

2:45 p.m.  
Anonymous Anónimo dijo...

xanax pill xanax for postpartum anxiety - xanax 106 s yellow pill

9:03 a.m.  
Anonymous Anónimo dijo...

buy cialis professional online buy cialis online new zealand - cialis $0.92

10:32 a.m.  
Anonymous Anónimo dijo...

cialis online cialis online in australia - buy cialis daily online

3:37 p.m.  
Anonymous Anónimo dijo...

buy cialis professional cialis moment urban dictionary - cialis daily available nhs

6:46 p.m.  
Anonymous Anónimo dijo...

learn how to buy tramdadol get off tramadol addiction - tramadol for dogs whining

2:42 p.m.  
Anonymous Anónimo dijo...

buy tramadol online buy from online texas tramadol - tramadol 50mg and xanax

5:40 a.m.  
Anonymous Anónimo dijo...

buy klonopin online klonopin dosage pictures - klonopin dosage .5

6:38 a.m.  
Anonymous Anónimo dijo...

learn how to buy tramdadol tramadol 450 mg - tramadol high duration

8:51 p.m.  
Anonymous Anónimo dijo...

learn how to buy tramdadol tramadol online credit card - can you really buy tramadol online

11:53 a.m.  
Anonymous Anónimo dijo...

klonopin 2mg 2mg klonopin once - klonopin side effects for children

11:46 a.m.  
Anonymous Anónimo dijo...

buy klonopin online long does 2mg klonopin last - strongest generic klonopin

4:47 p.m.  
Blogger Unknown dijo...

Este comentario ha sido eliminado por el autor.

2:07 a.m.  

Publicar un comentario

Suscribirse a Comentarios de la entrada [Atom]

<< Página Principal